Hiring the wrong person for a role can happen to even the most experienced managers. The costs are not just financial—there’s lost productivity, potential disruptions to team dynamics, and time spent redoing the hiring process. While it’s an unfortunate situation, the good news is that there are concrete steps you can take to address the issue. Here are three approaches you can take if you think you’ve hired the wrong person for the job:

© APchanel / Adobe Stock

1. Assess the Situation Thoroughly

It’s easy to jump to conclusions in the moment. However, it’s important to assess the situation properly with a level-headed approach first. Is the employee truly a bad fit for the role, or do they simply need more time to adjust? Have their job duties and performance expectations been communicated clearly during onboarding? Often, issues can arise from miscommunication or misaligned objectives. Review the employee’s performance, talk to their direct supervisors, and conduct a one-on-one meeting with the employee to get their perspective. By understanding the root cause, you can decide if they just need extra support, or if they are fundamentally wrong for the role.

2. Provide Targeted Training or Reassignment

If the employee shows potential but is struggling with specific tasks, consider offering additional training or mentoring. Sometimes a lack of experience or familiarity with company processes can be the issue, and with proper guidance, the employee might excel. However, if the skill gap is too wide, it might be worth considering a reassignment. Perhaps they’re better suited for a different position within the company. Reassigning them to a role that aligns more closely with their strengths can be a win-win solution, preserving the company’s investment in the hire while benefiting from the individual’s unique skills.

3. Plan for an Exit Strategy if Necessary

When it becomes clear that no amount of training or reassignment will resolve the situation, it’s crucial to act quickly. Holding onto an underperforming employee for too long can harm morale and productivity. Follow your company’s HR guidelines to begin a smooth exit process. Be professional, fair, and transparent in your communication, offering support like severance or outplacement services if appropriate. This ensures the transition is as painless as possible for both parties and allows the company to start searching for a better fit without unnecessary delay.

If you’ve hired the wrong person, it can be a challenging and awkward situation to overcome, but it’s not insurmountable. By thoroughly assessing the situation, exploring options like additional training or reassignment, and being prepared to take decisive action when necessary, upper-level management can effectively address the issue and protect the overall health of the organization.

Tempstar Staffing can help you manage your workforce and ensure that new employees are the best fit possible for your open positions. Contact us today to learn how we can level up your workforce.