When figuring out whether you’ve hired the right person for the job, it goes beyond checking off qualifications and experience. While a resume and interview can give you a good idea of someone’s potential, there are subtle cues that can reveal whether your new hire will be a true asset to your organization. These signs may not be immediately obvious, but recognizing them can help ensure long-term success for both the employee and your business.

Here are some ways to tell if you’ve hired the right person by focusing on these less apparent traits.

© Drazen / Adobe Stock

1. Emotional Intelligence: How Well Do They Navigate Social Dynamics?

Emotional intelligence (EQ) is an underrated but important aspect to pay attention to when evaluating a new hire. EQ describes the ability to understand and manage one’s emotions while also recognizing and influencing the emotions of others. Employees with high EQ tend to communicate better, handle conflict more effectively, and foster stronger team relationships.

Watch how your new hire reacts to constructive criticism, stress, and collaboration. Do they listen actively and respond thoughtfully? Are they able to maintain composure and professionalism even under pressure? These are indicators of emotional intelligence, which can often be a greater predictor of success than technical abilities alone.

2. Proactive Problem Solving: Do They Anticipate and Address Issues?

Another hidden indicator of a good hire is their ability to anticipate problems before they arise. While many employees will do well when assigned specific tasks, the right person will also take the initiative to identify potential issues and come up with solutions without being prompted.

Pay attention to whether your new hire is identifying opportunities for improvement, asking insightful questions, or offering solutions to challenges the team faces. This level of initiative and forward-thinking shows that they’re not just completing tasks but also actively contributing to the company’s growth.

3. Adaptability: How Do They Handle Change?

No matter what industry you’re in, change is inevitable. Whether it’s a shift in leadership, market trends, or technology, the right employee will be able to handle these changes with ease.

Consider how your new hire responds to unexpected shifts in workload or strategy. Are they flexible and open to new ideas, or do they seem stuck in their ways? Employees who can pivot quickly and stay positive during times of change will help keep your business agile and resilient.

When determining whether you’ve hired the right person, it isn’t just about checking off qualifications—it’s about finding someone who will thrive in your specific environment. By looking for hidden traits like emotional intelligence, proactive problem-solving, and adaptability, you’ll gain valuable insight into whether your new hire is truly the right fit for your company. Recognizing these subtleties early on can save you time, money, and effort, ensuring that your team continues to grow and succeed.

Want to hire a quality candidate that won’t disappoint? Contact us today to find out how Tempstar can help!